Party Walls

In part one of this blog series, we established that buildings are only sustainable if they are equitable and accessible for all occupants. In part two, we detailed how to apply these principles to the planning stages and provided resources for improving social outcomes in your projects. In this post, part three, we will outline ways in which we can integrate principles of social equity into the design, construction, and operations phases.

Design Phase

JUST Label (https://living-future.org/just/case-studies/ilfi/)

Stakeholders

The earlier you commit to an inclusive and integrative design process, the better. The broader the group of stakeholders involved, the better. For example, consider including members from the following groups, among others, to participate in early visioning and planning discussions and workshops:

• Leaders of local community groups;
• Members of future user groups (occupants, tenants, staff, operations team, people with disabilities, etc.);
• Public health professionals;
• Local policymakers and government officials;
• Representatives from local cultural organizations;
• Specialists in the local natural and social history, ecology, economy, ethnography, building code, etc.;
• Subject matter experts in sustainability, energy, accessibility, etc.

When possible, recruit project team members from companies that have committed to social responsibility by publishing a JUST Label or other social responsibility report. Companies can pursue a JUST Label and become a resource for others.

Creating Equitable Project Teams

Consider integrating criteria related to social responsibility, diversity, and accessibility compliance into your project’s RFQs/RFPs for consulting services.

• The intent of the LEED Social Equity within the Project Team Pilot Credit is to create “more equitable, healthier, and more supportive environments for construction workers during project construction,” and promote “corporate social responsibility at an organizational level by the firms of the project owner, financier, architects/engineers, contractors, product manufacturers, etc.”
• The WELL Feature Organizational Transparency promotes “transparency in organizations through adherence to and disclosure of equitable and inclusive social and business practices.“
• The Living Building Challenge 4.0 Imperative-18: Inclusion addresses “diversity in hiring and access to training.”

Once the project team has been assembled, work to foster and maintain a culture of inclusiveness and collaboration to ensure that each person has the opportunity to contribute to and shape the project as it develops. Check out this article on “How To Run a Great Workshop: 37 Tips and Ideas.”

Certification and Design Program Credits

When developing the project’s design, in addition to addressing the specific social equity goals established for the project, incorporate standard equitable design features and strategies that enhance the surrounding community. For example, a mixed-use project with maximized publicly accessible space and amenities (outdoor open space, public lobbies and restrooms, indoor weather shelters, etc.) will enhance the neighborhood. Or, incorporate Universal/Inclusive Design strategies that meet the 8 goals of Universal Design to accommodate the needs of all people, regardless of age, ability, stature, etc. One strategy to further integrate the project with the community would be to include space that can be used by community groups.

• The WELL Community Access and Engagement Feature provides “public spaces, amenities and programming for community members to gather social and collaborate.”
• The LEED Joint Use of Facilities Innovation in Design Credit integrates the school with the community by “sharing the building and its playing fields for non-school events and functions.”
• The LEED Visitability and Universal Design Credit increases “the proportion of areas usable by a wide spectrum of people, regardless of age or ability.”

Recognize that the needs of the surrounding community may shift and evolve over time, so designing for flexibility and adaptability is important. This may be accomplished by incorporating Universal Design goals, thereby maximizing the project’s usability and inclusivity. Include spaces such as lactation rooms, wellness/meditation rooms, all-gender and/or family restrooms, etc. and advocate for the owner/tenant(s) to adopt inclusive policies for staff working in the building, such as new parent leave, family leave, and bereavement support.

• The LEED Inclusive Design Pilot Credit encourages the design of spaces that ”empower a diverse population by improving human performance, health and wellness, and social participation.”
• The LEED Design for Accessibility Credit reduces “the materials needed for and waste produced from future maintenance, repair, ren-ovation and rehabilitation through structural, mechanical, and user-induced design.”
• Multiple WELL Features encourage inclusive policies for users of and staff in a given building: New Parent Support; New Mother Support; Family Support; Accessibility and Universal Design; and, Bathroom Accommodations.
• Living Building Challenge 4.0 Imperative 17: Universal Access allows “equitable access to, and protections from any negative impacts resulting from the development of, Living Building projects.”

Selecting Materials

Social LCA Framework (https://www.lifecycleinitiative.org/)

Integrate social equity goals into the material selection process to address social equity for those involved in the production of building materials and products. An initial strategy would be to incorporate social sustainability metrics into the life cycle analysis (LCA) “hot spot” study, so that different material and manufacturer options can be evaluated according to both environmental and social impacts (see discussions of the emerging Social Life Cycle Analysis (S-LCA) approach).

Using the information gathered during the initial “equity scan” of available products, develop the project specifications to maximize use of socially conscious and universally designed materials. Where accessibility compliance is required, ensure that products comply with applicable accessibility criteria (fairly sourced and traded from manufacturers that adhere to good labor practices and protect human rights, etc.). As a starting point, the project team could set a goal of using a percentage of products from companies that have published a JUST Label.

Advocate for potential suppliers to conduct assessments or complete and accept a Supplier Code of Conduct, based on criteria from an internationally recognized social responsibility guideline or standard, addressing health and safety procedures, non-discrimination, anti-corruption policies, etc.

• The LEED Social Equity within the Supply Chain Pilot Credit encourages members of the project team to “promote and further social equity by integrating strategies that address identified social and community issues, needs and disparities among those affected by the project.”

Periodic specification reviews can help ensure that social equity goals related to material supply are met.

Construction Phase

Photo: NIOSH (https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/)

During the construction phase, it is important to support the community by requiring that local construction labor be hired. If the project’s community is affected by a shortage of skilled workers, support initiatives to train local labor. Additionally, safe working conditions and fair labor practices can and should be advocated for and ensured.

The LEED Prevention through Design Pilot Credit can help to identify and address potential hazards to both construction workers and building maintenance staff during construction safety reviews. This process, undertaken with the general contractor and representatives from the trades and suppliers involved, will help ensure that the necessary equipment and protocols are in place to address potential health hazards. The strategies developed to protect worker and community safety during construction should be incorporated into all construction documents and plans and communicated to all personnel during contractor and operator training sessions.

Operations Phase

The owner and facilities team must know how the project was designed to promote social equity, environmental performance, and accessibility compliance. Building management and maintenance staff should understand the project’s social equity elements. The project team can assist by integrating information related to the project’s social equity features into the operations and maintenance plans and manual. Periodic review of the building’s O+M plans and policies can help ensure that they are inclusive and responsive to the needs of the occupants and surrounding community. For example, the project’s emergency preparedness plan should include particular guidance pertaining to the needs of the most vulnerable occupant group, as described in the WELL Emergency Preparedness Feature.

Provide Opportunities for Education and Feedback

Integrate educational features that communicate to occupants and the public how the project’s design was influenced by social equity concerns as a way to both advocate for socially equitable design and solicit feedback from building users with which to evaluate the project’s success.

Use post-occupancy review strategies to track and measure the extent to which the building is effectively addressing targeted social equity issues and to identify new concerns and/or opportunities. This process can inform the ongoing development of strategies the project may use throughout its life cycle to advance ”just sustainability” within its community.

• The WELL Precondition Occupant Survey Feature “requires projects to collect feedback from building users on their health and well-being.”
• The WELL Feature Enhanced Occupant Survey evaluates “comfort, satisfaction, behavior change, self-reported health and other robust factors related to the well-being of occupants in buildings.”

Additional Resources

AIA: Designing for Equitable Communities

SOCIAL EQUITY IN THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT: AN INITIAL FRAMEWORK AND PROJECT EXAMPLES

https://www.usgbc.org/sites/default/files/FINAL_Social%20Equity%20Built%20Environment_10.30.13.pdf

Social Equity in the Built Environment Learning Pathway

Advocacy Brief: Social Equity in Green Building Policies

Discover LEED projects that are building social equity

https://thehill.com/changing-america/opinion/505097-injustice-by-design-confronting-the-embedded-racism-of-americas

Written by James Wilson, Sustainability Consultant